It’s not that I am upset, or angry. I am just curious to know that where my answer went wrong. I answered someone’s question, he asked for further clarification, I clarified his doubt in the comments section, and he marked my answer as the accepted one. A few hours laters, my answer had a downvote and was no longer the accepted one (no problem with that though).

Link to the answer: https://ell.stackexchange.com/a/272954/122691

  • 3
    I am not the person that down-voted, but I think it is the mention of a "wheelchair" that might have done it. The question says A man sits in a chair at a Club. which is barely any context, but enough to maybe rule out that he was in a wheelchair. Even though you did say "or a chair with wheels", some people may react negatively to one thing being "off". – ColleenV Jan 22 at 16:27
  • Also, there is an FAQ on Meta: I've just been downvoted. How should I react? that has a lot of good advice. – ColleenV Jan 22 at 16:46
  • 1
    In this instance, it is pointless trying to figure out why this answer got downvoted. It's correct. It's well explained, and you did say it could be any chair with wheels. But Michael's answer is more complete, as a side issue, Italians do not put castors (small wheels) on home furniture, tables or on beds. It must be an anglo thing. – Mari-Lou A Jan 22 at 19:45
  • @Mari-LouA Thank you for appreciating :-), and yes, Michael’s answer was indeed more complete. – Ayden Ferguson Jan 22 at 20:52
  • 2
    Downvotes are anonymous. If you think your answer was correct then you shouldn't be worried about downvotes. See this answer of mine; it's my only answer that has an overall negative score, but it is correct and I share its link to every other answer about 'syncope'. I recently shared its link to another answer. (Honestly, I'm quite happy about the downvote because it makes it easier to search. :P) – Void Jan 22 at 20:58
  • @Void Should I take the opportunity to remove that negative score off your account forever? ;-D (I liked the answer though) – Ayden Ferguson Jan 22 at 21:38
  • Everything after the semicolon is supposition, and everything before it is the only thing on the entire page that I can agree with: "It means he moved his chair" (it does not mean it has wheels on it. Imaginary DVs for everyone ;) – Mazura Jan 23 at 4:19

As you know when people downvote they are not obliged to offer a comment to explain why. This topic has been extensively discuss over on Meta Encouraging people to explain downvotes and there is no chance that will change. This means that we can only guess as to why someone downvoted your answer. I cannot personally see any thing that stands out as demanding a downvote. I guess we will never know.

It might have been better if the OP had waited a while before accepting an answer in case something better came along. It is rather awkward if they change their mind and have to unaccept but it happens. There is no guarantee that the accepted answer is any better than any of the others, I have certainly seen cases where it was not. In this case though I think that on the balance of probabilities the current accepted answer is the correct one given the context of a club in the first decades of the last century.

  • 4
    RE: It might have been better if the OP had waited a while before accepting an answer in case something better came along. Absolutely agree that's case here. Moreover, some folks may be more inclined to downvote a hastily-accepted answer that isn't necessarily a great answer, especially on a learner's forum) – in part to signal the OP, "Hey, this isn't necessarily the stellar answer that you seemed to think it is." – J.R. Jan 23 at 13:44

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .