2

I've observed lately the overuse of the ampersand symbol "&" in some posts replacing the word "and". Including some replacements in quoted texts that originally do not use "&".

I think that this use is not common in formal English. Is there any style-guide for this site addressing this point? Should posts be edited and OPs advised or not?

  • 3
    If something is quoted incorrectly, you should edit it to match the source (just make sure you have the correct source!). – ColleenV Sep 5 '18 at 11:24
  • 1
    "&" should not be used solely as a shortcut to save two key presses or taps, though. – user3169 Sep 7 '18 at 3:55
5

Quotes should be quotes

If a user quotes material incorrectly, then it should be corrected. If the difference was intentional then it needs to be very clear what change was made (usually restricted to the very common "emphasis mine" or ellipses to reduce irrelevant information). Switching between "and" and "&" is unlikely to be harmful, but if something is represented as a quotation then it should be identical to the source including stylistic choices. There is some ambiguity if the quotation is from a spoken source, in which case different transcriptions might have different formatting.

The only time I might not be inclined to "repair" an inaccurate quotation through editing is if the quotation is in a question and that question depends on the inaccuracy so the answer to the question is "your quote is inaccurate".

"&" is not incorrect English

"&" might not strictly be "common" in either formal or informal English, but it is an entirely valid stylistic choice and there's no reason to edit it out or admonish its users. Unless you can point out specifically harm that occurs specifically because of the ampersand symbol appearing at a certain frequency, it should be left alone. There are some situations where only one is correct, mostly related to Quotes and similar concepts like the names of businesses, but otherwise neither version is problematic and there's no need to unify this stylistic choice across the site.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .