7

Suppose to a question, only a single answer has been posted and the single answer lacks a trivial information, which can easily be brought into the attention of the answerer by a comment to his answer. So in that case, should I add another answer adding the trivial information? I am asking this question because in this way, Q/A ratio of this site can be improved which is a criteria For a site's success according to Area51. Also relevantly asking, should we down-vote if a duplicate answer is posted adding nothing more to the existing answer?

| |
  • 1
    There are good rationales for both sides of the argument, and I think it's probably a case-by-case sort of thing. I would like to say that I don't think affecting the Area51 stats on purpose is a good reason to post an extra answer. Quality over quantity will probably get us to graduate after all! :) – WendiKidd Feb 18 '13 at 22:35
  • 1
    What @WendiKidd said. I think TPTB would strongly advise us not to attempt to artificially distort Area51 stats for any reason, so I'd dismiss that "argument" immediately. I'll also add that I personally occasionally downvote an answer that's not actually wrong, if I think it was added significantly after an answer covering the same points, if the later one it doesn't even have the benefit of being better phrased. Multiple answers saying the same thing just create "noise", imho. – FumbleFingers Reinstate Monica Feb 18 '13 at 23:58
8

You could add another answer, or you could just add your information as a comment. Both are acceptable in my mind.

Are such minor additions better left as a comment or an answer? Sometimes it's obvious, like when the comment box displays this message: -11 characters left.

Other times, it's more of a judgment call, and I suppose it depends in part on how "trivial" the addition would be. (Sometimes an extra comment will have enough substance that it's hard to tell exactly how "trivial" the information really is.) But if such information really does add to the completeness of an answer, I think it ought to be added – one way or the other.

One practice I've seen from time to time is to preface such answers by calling out the original answerer by name; something like this:

I think Mistu4u covered this pretty well in his answer, but I would like to add one thing...

I suppose there's a third option, too: one could edit the information in. However, many users feel a little funny about editing someone else's answer to add content (as opposed to making a correction). I'd probably only do that in rare instances. That said, I've seen where someone left me a helpful comment, and then later encouraged me to edit it into my answer myself, saying:

Add that to your answer; I'll delete my comment.

It's nice to see such obliging civility on the network. That makes my day, actually.

| |
  • +1 for civility. On this list, I'd usually go for comment; on some others, I feel free to edit. – barbara beeton Feb 18 '13 at 18:28
  • 1
    I'll note that I really, really hate answers that start off "I think so-and-so covered this pretty well, I just want to add...". This results in neither answer being complete/correct. If it really is just a minor thing, add a comment. If it's not, post a complete answer of your own. Don't try to sit on both chairs at once, because you'll just end up on the floor. – Martha Feb 20 '13 at 22:34
2

I think it depends from which information you would add. If the information is relevant, and important for those users who read the question (and its answers) that cannot be buried under X comments, with the risk it goes unobserved, then it deserves to be an answer. IMO, the answer still needs to answer the question, even if partially.

In any case, I would not add an answer just to increase the average number of answers per question. Statistics about the site should not drive what we do; they are used to check how the site is going, but we should not be influenced from them.
Then, it is not said that not having the minimum number average answers per question would prevent ELL from graduating: The requirements are evaluated together, not singularly. See for example Drupal Answers statistics: The number of answers is 1.7, but the site graduated.

screenshot

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .